THE DIVISION THAT DIVIDES US: The fracture no one wants to name

THE DIVISION THAT DIVIDES US: The fracture no one wants to name

November 19, 2026 Off By Mike

The greatest challenge in interpreting global events, such as the elections in the USA, the presence of refugees in Europe, or the current wars in Gaza and Iran, is not simply a lack of biblical knowledge. It is contained in the lenses we use to interpret scripture.  The reality is that almost every Christian conviction comes weaponised with its own collection of Bible verses and the belief that its interpretation carries the endorsement of God.

Global events themselves do not divide the Church. The Church has often faced similar events while arriving at very different conclusions. What divides us is the way Scripture is used, interpreted, and applied. The same Bible is frequently cited to support opposing viewpoints, each claiming divine sanction.

This article does not primarily seek to examine the events themselves. Rather, it explores the deeper fault line that runs through the Christian community: the disagreement over how we read Scripture and discern God’s voice in a world marked by conflict, suffering, and competing narratives.

James 4:1 “What causes fights and quarrels among you? Don’t they come from your desires that battle within you?”

James 4:1 refers to the mind, not the heart.

The church is divided — but not in the way we think.  The real division is not conservative vs liberal, pro-Israel or pro-Palestine, pro-Trump or anti-Trump, LGBTQ+ or straight, traditional vs renewal, or even West vs East.

The real division beneath these divisions lies within those who interpret Christ through Scripture vs those who interpret Scripture through Christ.

One group defends the text even when it contradicts Jesus. The other follows Jesus even when He reinterprets the text.  This is the division beneath the division — and it is tearing the church apart.

The events of 7 October 2023 did not create division; it exposed it. It exposed the fractures already present within the Church — fractures formed by years of cultural battles, theological rigidity, and political entanglement. Many believers responded not from the heart of Christ, but from the reflexes of their tribe. Scripture was used as ammunition. Theology became a shield. Social media became a battlefield.

But beneath all of this was something more painful: a loss of sight.  Jesus stood before His disciples in John 4 and said, “Lift your eyes.” He did not say, “Choose a side.” He did not say, “Defend your position.” He did not say, “Prove your righteousness.” He said, “Look. Look at the people. Look at the pain. Look at the fields. Look at the humanity. Look at the harvest.”

2,000 years later, and the Church is still not looking. It is reacting.

And reaction without revelation always leads to division.

When scripture becomes a wall instead of a window

The deepest fracture in the Church is not doctrinal disagreement — it is the lens through which Scripture is read.  For some, Scripture is the final authority even when Jesus challenges its interpretation. For others, Jesus is the final authority even when He challenges Scripture’s traditional reading.

He did so by continually and intentionally training His disciple into a new mental mindset.  “You have heard that it was said…” He would instruct them “But I tell you…”  And this would always be followed by a new interpretation of old religious instructions.  The teachings of Christ were always challenging the “old” mindset that saw “them” as a threat into a new mindset of treating “them” like neighbours

Today, both groups claim to honour the Bible. Both groups claim to follow Christ. But only one group allows Jesus to be the window through which Scripture is understood. The other uses Scripture as the wall through which Jesus is constrained.

This is why the same Bible can produce radically different Christians: Some who look like Jesus, and some who look like the Pharisees who opposed Him.

The Pharisees were not irreligious. They were not secular. They were not biblically illiterate. They were experts in Scripture — and yet blind to Christ.  Their problem was not a lack of knowledge; it was the wrong interpretive centre. They interpreted Christ through Scripture. Jesus interpreted Scripture through Himself.

And that difference changed everything.

The danger of a Christless Christianity

When Scripture is read without Christ at the centre, it becomes a weapon. It becomes a system. It becomes a boundary marker. It becomes a tool for exclusion, justification, and tribal identity.  It justifies war.  It supports genocide.  It opposes peace plans.  It divides and excludes

It becomes Christianity without Christ.

This is why believers can quote verses while ignoring suffering. Why they can defend doctrine while abandoning compassion. Why they can fight for truth while failing to love.

A Christless Christianity is always a violent Christianity — not necessarily physically, but spiritually, emotionally, and relationally. It wounds. It excludes. It divides. It blinds.

It produces Christians who know the Bible but do not resemble Jesus.

The call back to the centre

The division beneath the division is ultimately a crisis of sight.  The Church has lost its ability to see Christ clearly — and therefore has lost its ability to see Scripture clearly. Because Scripture without Christ is a closed book. Christ without Scripture is an incomplete story. But Scripture interpreted through Christ becomes revelation. And Christ revealed through Scripture becomes transformation.

This is the interpretation of the Kingdom: Jesus is the centre. Jesus is the lens. Jesus is the meaning. Jesus is the message.

When we return to Christ as the interpretive centre, the fractures begin to heal. Not because we agree on everything, but because we finally see the One who holds everything together.

The harvest we are missing

The tragedy of an unrenewed mind is not only theological — it is missional. While the Church argues about Scripture, the world bleeds. While believers defend their positions, the harvest stands waiting. While Christians fight over interpretations, people long for the presence of Jesus.

The fields are white. The pain is deep. The hunger is real. The moment is urgent.

But we cannot see the harvest until we see Christ. And we cannot see Christ until He becomes the lens through which we see everything else.

This is the division beneath the division — and the invitation beneath the invitation:  Return to Jesus. Read through Jesus. See through Jesus. Live through Jesus. Love through Jesus.

Only then will the Church regain its sight. Only then will the fractures begin to mend. Only then will the harvest become visible again.